Pain, Pills, and Perception: Why We Trust What Feels Intense

Marketing is not just about selling a product; it’s about selling a belief. Consumers don’t just buy products—they buy experiences, expectations, and perceptions. One of the most fascinating psychological phenomena that influence consumer behavior is the Placebo Effect—where people experience real effects simply because they believe something is working.

This is especially true for products that claim medical, health, or performance-enhancing benefits. A product’s effectiveness is not just determined by its ingredients but also by how it feels, tastes, or behaves when consumed.

Pexels / cottonbro studio

For instance, any consumable product that claims to have medicinal properties must taste slightly strange for people to believe it’s working. Imagine a painkiller that tasted like candy—would you take it seriously? Probably not. This is why cough syrups are often bitter and energy tonics have a strong aftertaste. The unpleasantness of the taste reinforces the belief that the medicine is potent and effective. If diet soda tasted exactly like regular soda, consumers might subconsciously doubt its low-calorie nature. That’s why Diet Coke has a slightly bitter aftertaste—it signals to the consumer that they are drinking a healthier alternative.

Similarly, products applied to the skin often include sensations like tingling, stinging, or warming effects. This is common in skincare and cosmetic products, especially in anti-aging creams, acne treatments, and hair regrowth solutions. Consumers expect some level of discomfort, as it convinces them that the product is actively working. A face cream that causes a slight burning sensation feels more potent than one that is completely soothing, even if both contain the same ingredients. This is why brands intentionally add ingredients like menthol, alcohol, or capsicum extracts—not necessarily because they enhance effectiveness, but because they create a perceived sensation of effectiveness.

The same logic applies to personal care and fitness products. A gym supplement that has an intense, chalky aftertaste or a pre-workout drink that makes your skin tingle feels more powerful than a smooth, mild alternative. Even in luxury goods, perceived effectiveness plays a crucial role. High-end perfumes often have a strong, overpowering initial note, creating an illusion of longer-lasting scent, even if the actual fragrance fades at the same rate as a lighter alternative.

Marketers and advertisers must understand that consumers don’t just rely on logical decision-making when assessing a product’s effectiveness. A large part of their belief system is driven by sensory cues—taste, texture, scent, and even color. This is why energy drinks are often neon-colored and come in aggressive-looking packaging. A neutral-colored drink in a plain bottle would not feel as energizing, even if the formula were identical.

Understanding this psychological aspect of consumer behavior allows brands to design products that “feel” effective, not just in composition but in experience. Whether it’s a bitter taste, a tingling sensation, or a strong fragrance, subtle cues shape perceptions and influence purchasing decisions. The lesson for marketers is clear: effectiveness isn’t just about results—it’s about perception. And sometimes, making a product slightly unpleasant can actually make it more desirable.

Connect with Us